Stay Roasted is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
While most people associate pumpkin spice coffee with Starbucks, you don’t always need to go to their coffee shops to get the beverage. Instead, you can buy the flavored beans and brew the beverage in the comfort of your home. That said, pumpkin spice coffee varies from pack to pack.
You can see this in the roast options, the pack’s weight, type of beans used, whether it comes as whole beans or grounds, and other features. For most coffee drinkers, these features make all the difference in terms of whether they enjoy their beverages or not. Ultimately, if you want to know the best pumpkin spice coffee pack to buy, we’ve taste-tested and reviewed multiple options in the market. The list below consists of the packs we view as the crème of the crop.
Other features: low acid, shade-grown, non-GMO, Fair Trade, single-origin
The Lifeboost Coffee is one of the best pumpkin spice coffee packs in the market. It comes either as whole bean or ground coffee, depending on whether you have a grinder at home or not. Also, this low-acid, single-origin option is only available as medium roast coffee and thus is excellent for boosting your metabolism.
A couple of features differentiate this pack from other options, including the single-origin, fair trade, and non-GMO sourcing. Additionally, being available in both whole bean and ground configurations means it serves a broader range of preferences.
What stands out?
The low acidity is, in our opinion, one of the highlights of the coffee pack. Additionally, since it uses single-origin beans that are medium roasted, users experience some unique coffee flavors. Lastly, there’s a lot of attention to detail that ensures you get the best coffee possible, including fair trade sourcing of non-GMO beans.
What cons did we manage to find?
First, there’s only one bag size available, and although you can get it as a subscription, it might not work well for some households. Additionally, there’s only the medium roast variation. As such, coffee drinkers who prefer lighter roasts for the bright flavors or darker roasts for their body will have to look elsewhere.
Given that the history of pumpkin spice coffee intertwines with Starbucks, it makes sense that Starbucks also sells the coffee for home use. The Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Ground Limited Edition is a 35 oz pack consisting of 100% arabica beans. This pack is also lightly roasted, so users will experience more than just the pumpkin spice flavors.
Users who prefer the brighter flavors of light roast coffee will be satisfied with the Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Ground Limited Edition.
What makes it stand out?
First, the light roast of the coffee means that you get to experience more of the fruity flavors of the beans in addition to the pumpkin spice flavors. Additionally, the pack caters well to the needs of large households. Lastly, since the coffee comes pre-ground, it’s more convenient as all you have to do is measure and brew.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?
While ground coffee is more convenient since you don’t have to buy a grinder or spend a few minutes grinding your coffee, it still loses flavor and aroma a lot faster than whole bean coffee. Additionally, the 35-oz pack is an asset for large households but will likely be overkill for smaller ones.
If you want pumpkin spice coffee with more body, then the DEATH WISH COFFEE Organic Pumpkin Chai Coffee is an ideal pick. It’s dark roasted and packaged in 12 oz bags, just like the editor’s choice. Also, it’s both USDA organic and Fair Trade certified, and that should give you an idea of the sourcing practices.
The differentiating factors for this coffee are that it’s Fair Trade sourced, the beans are organic, and it’s dark roasted in addition to the pumpkin spice flavoring.
What makes it special?
First, the availability in both whole bean and pre-ground variations means it caters well to people who own grinders and those without. Additionally, the beans used are organic, meaning you ingest fewer chemicals with your caffeinated beverages. Lastly, due to the fair trade certification, buyers are certain that the coffee farmers aren’t taken advantage of by the company.
What cons did we find?
In our opinion, only having 12 oz packs limits the pack’s ability to service the needs of some consumers. Next, users who like the brighter flavors of light-roast coffee need to look at other alternatives as this option is only available as a dark roast. Also, it feels weak, therefore, necessitating that you use more grinds per brew.
Other features: 100% arabica, artisan roasted, vegan and keto-friendly, dairy-free
Another 12 oz pack to make it to this list is the Bones Coffee Jacked ‘O’ Lantern Pumpkin Spice. This pick is dairy-free in addition to being both vegan and keto-friendly. Also, if you prefer to keep it fresher for longer, you can get it as whole beans. Alternatively, if you don’t have a grinder, a pre-ground variation is also available.
If you’re a coffee enthusiast who prefers artisan roasted coffee, this is the option for you. Additionally, it’s excellent if you’re vegan or on the keto diet.
What stands out?
In our opinion, this pumpkin spice coffee pack caters to a larger market by considering vegan coffee enthusiasts and those on keto or vegan diets. Additionally, being artisan roasted means there is a degree of care in every bean, which you might not get otherwise. Lastly, the availability of both whole beans and pre-ground coffee is a plus.
What cons did we manage to find?
Like with some of the other pumpkin spice coffee packs mentioned above, having different pack sizes would cater well to different size households, and it’s not something you get with this option. Also, there are no variations to the roast level, and consequently, this can put off buyers who prefer lighter or darker roasts.
Other features: 100% Arabica, compatible with Keurig 2.0
If you have a K-cup coffee maker, one of the options you should consider is the Dunkin’ Donuts Pumpkin Spice Coffee. It’s compatible with most Keurig coffee brewers, including the 2.0. Also, it consists of 100% arabica coffee and comes in a pack of 24. As for the roast, it’s medium-roasted.
This option differentiates itself by being compatible with K-cup coffee brewers, therefore guaranteeing a less messy brewing experience. Also, the grinds are kept fresher for longer, thanks to the seals in the K-cups.
What makes it stand out?
Its compatibility with multiple K-cup brewers makes this option easy to brew if you have the right equipment. Also, the coffee grinds come pre-portioned, which means you won’t have to waste time measuring them. Lastly, there’s not much cleanup needed after using one of these K-cups to brew a cup.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?
There are only a limited number of K-cup compatible machines in the market. Also, statistically, most people have alternative coffee machines meaning the market for these K-cups is relatively limited. Finally, thanks to the pre-portioning and packaging, we noticed you can’t adjust the strength of each brew to your liking.
Another Keurig machine compatible pack is the Community Coffee Spiced Pumpkin Pecan Pie Coffee Pods. This option comes with 80 pods, each with 0.38 oz of coffee, and thus should last you longer than the Dunkin’ Donuts Pumpkin Spice Coffee. That said, it also uses Arabica coffee and is medium-roasted, so they have that in common with its predecessor on the list.
This pick is excellent if you have a K-cup compatible machine and want your purchase to last longer or you have a bigger household.
Why did it make our list?
The number of pods available in each pack works well if you have a bigger household or you’d rather not have to buy a new bag every week. Also, like the Dunkin' Donuts Pumpkin Spice Coffee, this pack’s pods are compatible with multiple Keurig machines, including the 2.0. There’s also the convenience of using pods.
What is not ideal about it?
While there are 80 single-serve pods in the pack, there’s no denying that the package is pretty expensive especially compared to ground and whole bean alternatives. Also, most coffee drinkers won’t have compatible machines. Lastly, in our opinion, adjusting the strength of the coffee brew to match your drinking preferences also becomes more challenging with this pick.
The Volcanica Coffee Pumpkin Spice Flavored Coffee is the only kosher-certified pick listed. It’s less expensive while packing more coffee in the bag. As such, the value for money is excellent. Lastly, it’s similar to a few other pumpkin spice coffee pack options listed, given that it consists solely of arabica coffee.
If you’re a jew, this is the pumpkin spice coffee pack for you since it’s kosher certified. You can also stock this in your house to cater to your Jewish friends or family members.
Why are we impressed?
In our opinion, this option offers excellent value for money in terms of affordability and the amount of coffee in each pack. The kosher certification means Jews can use it without infringing on their religious beliefs. Of course, even people with other religious affiliations can use it as well. Lastly, it’s available in both whole bean and pre-ground variations.
What negatives must you be aware of?
While the coffee caters to jews, it may not cater as well to other groups such as vegetarians or coffee enthusiasts on the keto diet. Also, there’s no guarantee of fair trade dealings between the roaster and the growers of the coffee. Lastly, if you prefer organic and non-GMO blends, this is not the coffee for you.
Things to Consider
Finding a great pack of pumpkin spice coffee isn’t as easy as you might think. There are multiple lackluster options that will have you regretting your purchase as soon as you taste the first cup. Thankfully you can learn how to shop for and pick these coffees with this buying guide.
How to Pick the Best Pumpkin Spice Coffee?
If you’re going to pick the best pumpkin spice coffee, you will have to consider the variables below.
Pre-ground coffee allows you more control over the coffee strength and makes the brewing process less complicated
Notably, not all pumping spice coffee packs are the same as you’ve seen from the list above. The beans or grounds inside may differ in terms of the species, how they’re processed, and multiple other factors which can lead to variations in taste and experience.
For instance, you’re more likely to encounter either robusta or Arabica coffee in terms of the species. According to the World Trade Center
Trusted Source11.9.1-Coffee quality-Robusta - the speciesCoffea canephora, popularly known as robusta because of the hardy nature of the plant, was first discovered in the former Belgian Congo in the 1800s. It is also known to be indigenous to the tropical forests around the Lake Victoria crescent in Uganda.
, robusta or “Coffea canephora” represents between 30% and 40% of the world’s coffee production. On the other hand, Arabica makes up most of the difference, although there are a few other species that are not as common.
Depending on the source, Arabica has a sweeter and smoother taste with fruity, sugary, or chocolatey notes. Robusta has a harsher and stronger taste overall, and if you’re aware of this difference as well as your preference between the two, you’ll know which pack to pick.
Also, coffee is packaged either as whole bean, pre-ground or as pods. Whole bean coffee tends to preserve the flavor of the beans better than the other alternatives. However, it needs more equipment to brew and makes the brewing process more complicated.
With pre-ground coffee, you get control over the strength of your coffee, and it’s more convenient. However, it loses flavor and aroma much faster than the rest.
Pod coffee is the most convenient, but it doesn’t work with most machines, and even if it does, you have almost no control over portioning and brew strength.
Ultimately each coffee variation has its pros and cons, and evaluating all of them as well as deciding your preferences will help you pick the right pumpkin spice coffee for you.
Organic vs Non-Organic
Another differentiator in coffee is whether it’s organic or non-organic. Organic coffee like the DEATH WISH COFFEE Organic Pumpkin Chai Coffee is generally better because there are minimal chemicals in the production process. As such, it’s healthier than the non-organic alternative. However, it’s often more expensive, and you might have to look at your wallet before deciding on the purchase.
Artificial vs Authentic Flavoring
Even though the artificial flavoring provides a stronger smell and is less expensive, we recommend going for authentic flavoring
You may also encounter both artificial and authentic flavoring. Authentic flavoring such as in the Community Coffee Spiced Pumpkin Pecan Pie Coffee Pods will typically incorporate natural spices. On the other hand, artificial flavoring may incorporate synthetically processed components made to mimic the pumpkin spice flavors. Both will give you pumpkin spice coffee.
Nevertheless, lab-made flavors tend to have a stronger smell compared to the taste. However, with natural or authentic flavors, you get the best of both worlds without ingesting chemicals. As such, if you can afford it, we advise going for authentic flavoring. However, the raw materials for authentic flavoring are expensive, and this is likely to reflect in the product’s pricing.
Roast and Strength
The National Coffee Association
Trusted SourceCoffee Roasts GuideRoasting brings out the aroma and flavor that is locked inside the green coffee beans. Beans are stored green, a state in which they can be kept without loss of quality or taste.
classifies coffee into four major roast categories. Light roasts, medium roasts, medium-dark roasts, and dark roasts. This affects the strength of the coffee as well, with light roasts having the highest caffeine content. Darker roasts, on the other hand, have the least caffeine.
Additionally, there are flavor changes as well. Light roasts like the Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Ground Limited Edition have bright flavors, and you can taste the fruity or chocolatey notes in the brew. Conversely, darker roasts have bold, smoky flavors. They’re also less acidic.
Most coffee drinkers have a preference between these two, and deciding on yours will make it more likely that you’ll get pumpkin spice coffee that you enjoy. There’s also medium roast coffee like the Bones Coffee Jacked ‘O’ Lantern Pumpkin Spice which is the middle point between dark and light roasts.
Since coffee quality deteriorates with time, you’d better make sure the pack you are buying is not too big
As we’ve mentioned severally, the pack weight could also determine your enjoyment of the coffee. Large packs are great if you don’t plan on buying the coffee regularly or you have a large family. More miniature packs like the 12 oz Lifeboost Pumpkin Spice Coffee are preferred if you like your coffee fresh or you have a smaller household.
That said, it’s important to note that coffee quality deteriorates with time, even if it’s just sitting there without being used. As such, you don’t want to buy too big a pack.
Lastly, go for pumpkin spice coffee that you can afford as there are various options at different price points, and with enough effort, you should find one in your budget range.
Pumpkin spice coffees contain too many calories, and it may not be advisable to consume them regularly. However, you can still make it work if you factor in the calories in your diet plans and remove sugar from the equation.
In some cases, pumpkin spice can cause you headaches depending on whether it contains artificial flavoring as well as the preservatives used to keep it fresh for longer. As such, if you’re experiencing headaches every time you ingest pumpkin spice coffee, it may be time to look for another caffeinated beverage choice.
Coffea canephora, popularly known as robusta because of the hardy nature of the plant, was first discovered in the former Belgian Congo in the 1800s. It is also known to be indigenous to the tropical forests around the Lake Victoria crescent in Uganda.