Stay Roasted is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Despite having sparkling product descriptions, some of the Colombian coffee options you purchase will have you wanting your money back. Also, mistakes while buying coffee are quite common. As such, you may think you are purchasing the best Colombian coffee but end up sorely disappointed.
During thorough research of the products, we’ve taken a look at two dozen brands to determine the 8 best Colombian coffee brands and the best products to represent them. Different types of beans will yield different tastes and results even after similar processing methods. This is a crucial consideration alongside the roast type (light, medium, or dark). You also need a faint idea of what the coffee will taste like; hence you should check the flavors incorporated. Lastly, the net weight is a big issue as you are looking to buy the best Colombian coffee. We’ve decided to make the Pablo's Pride Gourmet Coffee Guatemala our Editor’s Choice since it is a great go-to option.
Flavor: medium-bodied, a very smooth cocoa toned finish
Net weight: 2 lb.
Other features: GMO-Free, low acidity, artisan roasted in small batches
The Don Pablo Colombian Supremo lives up to its name, hence the reason it is our first pick. While the main roasting categories are light, medium, and dark, you also encounter some like the medium-dark roast of this coffee.
Medium-dark roasts are a step above medium roast and a step below dark roasts. The outlook of these coffee beans is unique in that they are darker than medium roast beans. Also, oil starts to be visible on the surface of the beans.
You will likely see these characteristics since the package contains whole coffee beans. Despite having been processed, the beans will stay fresher for longer in the package since they haven’t been ground.
Remember that with whole coffee beans, you can choose the level of grinding if you know how it will affect the beverage you make. However, this brings up a problem where grinding coffee is an almost daily requirement.
There is as well the inconvenience of having to clean the coffee grinder often. That being said, you get 2 lbs of coffee in the Don Pablo Colombian Supremo package. Also, if you don’t get a smooth cocoa toned flavor after brewing a cup, you might be getting the brewing process wrong.
As mentioned above, the coffee is healthier since it is GMO-free. Lastly, this is a low acidity coffee product.
What stands out?
Freshness is maintained for longer since the coffee isn’t pre-ground
Users have control over how to grind and brew the coffee
What cons did we manage to find?
You need to go through the process of grinding the coffee any time you make a cup
This coffee also leads to more inconveniences where washing dishes is concerned
Flavor: subtle citrus aroma and hints of cocoa and brown sugar
Net weight: 12 oz. (3-pack)
Other features: full-bodied, smooth finish, roasted and packed in the USA
Despite the measurement units being different, the AmazonFresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee and the Don Pablo Colombian Supremo have similar bag sizes. The coffee, as implied in the name, is sourced from Colombia.
The raw product is packed fresh from the farm and shipped to the U.S, where it is then roasted before being put in the final package.
Coffee enthusiasts should know that the beans being roasted in huge batches can be detrimental to the quality of the product. The manufacturer, however, knows to avoid this and is particular about the size of the batches roasted.
When you do finally brew a cup, the most prominent flavors you should encounter are cocoa and brown sugar. Finally, a citrus aroma is a characteristic that you have to welcome if you are going to purchase this bag of coffee.
Moreover, with the medium roast, expect a balance in everything from flavor and acidity to aroma and caffeine levels.
What are our favorite features?
Shipped as whole beans hence the product can be kept fresh for longer
What could be better?
The flavor is underwhelming for some
Also, some people dislike the aftertaste of the coffee
You may also have purchased a Keurig coffee maker instead of standard coffee machines. This would limit you to using k-cup pods rather than regular ground coffee. If you are in such a scenario and still want to drink Colombian coffee, the Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select is excellent for your needs.
Flavor-wise this is one of the richest coffee options you can select. You get to taste caramel, plums, apricots, and cocoa all in one product. The Green Mountain Coffee is a medium roast, and there are 72 containers in the pack.
Lastly, Jews are not left out of the equation as the pods have received a Kosher certification from the Orthodox Union Kosher agency.
What do we love it for?
No portioning required
Easy to brew
What were we disappointed with?
Requires specialized coffee making equipment
Some people prefer a stronger coffee taste than the product has to offer
The most expensive coffee purchase on our list is the Folgers 100% Colombian Medium Roast Ground Coffee. It costs more than $40; however, you get six-packs of the same. The packs in question all offer 24.2 oz of ground coffee.
The facility making this coffee is in New Orleans and adheres to high production standards. Consequently, the medium-roast coffee that comes from this company is a favorite for many.
Also, as the name suggests, this is a ground coffee product; hence coming in a can is a plus.
What are our favorite features?
Easy to prepare
Roasted in the U.S
Flavors are impressive
What could be better?
The initial cost is relatively high though you do get good value for your money
This 35.27 oz pack of one is another one that users can purchase if they love Colombian coffee. Since the Andes mountains are well known for their high-quality coffee, the coffee beans are taken from there before being transported to the manufacturing facility.
You might need to purchase an airtight, opaque container if you do not own one already. This is so that you can transfer the coffee from the bag to the container for better storage. You store it in an airtight container since this is ground coffee, and leaving the coffee in an open bag can lead to problems later on.
If you could refrigerate the product after putting it into the container, then the shelf life will be extended even more.
Lastly, the low acidity may be precisely what some of you are looking for.
Another canned ground coffee option available is the Don Francisco’s 100% Colombia Supremo Ground Coffee. The manufacturer uses Colombian coffee beans that are then roasted, ground, then put into three containers.
What sets this Colombian coffee apart is the winey notes users get. This is in addition to a floral aroma. Also, each container out of the three is 12 oz, and that totals 36 oz for the three containers.
You should also note how affordable this pack is. Remember that whether you re-use the containers or discard them is up to you.
What stands out?
You get three containers for easier storage of the ground coffee
The Solimo Medium Roast Coffee Pods work well with k-cup brewers if you have one. If you don’t, we may suggest either buying the machine or staying clear of the Colombian coffee k cups.
Each pod is meant for making only one cup of your favorite brew. Also, the pods total 100, which means that you get 33 oz total net weight. If this is enough and you don’t mind floral flavors, you can purchase this product.
What makes it special?
Easy to brew
You can get up to 100 brews from the pack
1-year satisfaction guarantee
What cons did we find?
You need a k-cup brewer for the most effective brewing process with this pods
Things to Consider
Giving you some excellent Colombian coffee options is not enough to get you to pick the best option. Instead, you need instructions to show you how to go about the buying process to achieve optimum results. These instructions are given in the buying guide below.
What is so special about Colombian coffee?
There are some reasons why Colombian coffee is preferable to a large section of the population. Key among them is the Arabica coffee type grown in the country. The coffee is in a lot of situations considered better than Robusta.
Others will point out that you should purchase Colombian coffee due to its well-balanced and mild taste. A silky body is also characteristic of the coffee, and medium to high acidity levels are expected as well.
Additional, the sweet aromas and the taste of tropical fruits are other common characteristics.
Features to consider when choosing coffee with Colombian flavor
Just because all the coffee options above come from Colombia doesn’t mean that they taste the same. The fact is that two Colombian coffee options would give very different satisfaction levels to the same individual.
With experience and some extra information, people can tell if the Colombian coffee is for them by reading the features list and product description. This extra information is presented below. Use it to help you decide on the best option to purchase.
Whole beans vs. ground coffee
Once you open a container or bag of coffee, you will either encounter ground coffee or whole coffee beans. People who gravitate towards ground coffee like it for its convenience. You measure the quantity that you want, put it in your coffee machine, and wait for the beverage to be done.
Coffee beans require that you grind them first before you put them in your coffee machine. However, since the product is kept fresh for longer, you get to experience flavors and aromas in their full richness when you brew fresh cups.
Noteworthy is that coffee pods are all filled with ground coffee. Also, there are differences in the grinding outcomes as well. You can get to choose from superfine grounds to extra course grounds. In between these two, there are five other types of grinds. They include fine grounds, medium-fine grounds, medium grounds, medium-coarse grounds, and course grounds.
The uses of the product and the way you brew your coffee is different for each of these types. For example, finding super fine grounds in anything other than Turkish coffee is rare. As to the fine grounds, you will see them in espresso coffee.
If you use a vacuum coffee maker, buying medium-fine coffee is in your best interests. Also, the same grounds can be used for pour-over coffee preparation. As for those who like drip coffee, you should purchase medium grounds like the Café Sello Rojo Traditional Coffee.
Medium-coarse grinds may take at least two minutes to prepare and work best if you are using a Chemex coffee maker.
Those using a French press coffee maker should know the machine doesn’t filter coffee well. This being the case, the larger particles of coarse-grind coffee are ideal for use with the machine. Lastly, for those who like cold brews, you can go with the extra course ground option.
Due to the diversity of the climate as well as the landscape of Colombia, coffee from different parts of the country is quite different. For example, coffee grown in the northern region of the country is chocolate and nutty in flavor. If you don’t like high acidity in your brews as well, coffee from this area will be an excellent purchase.
Fruity flavors in coffee are what some of you are looking for. In that case, you should buy Colombian coffee from the central region. You get medium acidity and medium body as well from the beverages.
Higher acidity is there in coffee from the southern region. Caramel and fruity notes can be present as well.
Type of beans
You may already know that Arabica coffee is the primary type found in Colombia. As such, it may confuse you to find coffee from the country being called Bourbon, Typica, Caturra, Tabi, Colombia, Maragogipe, or Castillo. However, these are all subspecies of Arabica coffee. For some of these subspecies, the differences include the sizes of the beans produced, yield, and resistance to pests and diseases.
Another sub-category describing Colombian coffee is the roast type. Remember that the level of roasting will affect the color and taste of the coffee. As you move from a light roast to an extra dark roast, the color of the roasted beans gets darker.
Also, the darker the roast, the less the caffeine levels in the product. The options here are light, medium, dark, and finally, extra dark roast. Another phenomenon that you experience less off the darker you go is acidity in the coffee.
Lastly, you should know that the bitterest option is that of the extra dark coffee. Light coffee has a toasted grain taste, while the medium coffee roast has medium flavors.
For a lot of people, the flavors they want are available if they are willing to look for them. You can find nutty, citrus, fruity, and even mild ones on the list above.
Organic vs. non-organic
Remember that some coffee growers choose to use chemical fertilizers and products to ensure high yields. Some of you would rather drink coffee with no chemical additives whatsoever. If you are in this group of people, pick organic coffee over the non-organic option. The latter, however, might be less costly to purchase.
Additionally, if a product is fair trade certified, you know that the coffee farmers in Colombia are getting reasonable pay for selling the manufacturer the beans. This way, you know nobody is unfairly exploited.
Remember to plan for how long you intend to drink the coffee. The pack with a higher net weight is bound to last longer. Consequently, the Folgers 100% Colombian Medium Roast Ground Coffee takes the cake here despite being the most expensive. After all, you do get about 9 lbs of coffee in the purchase.
Colombian coffee is a variation of the product where the raw materials are grown and sourced from Colombia. Since the country’s primary focus is Arabica coffee beans, you will likely never see Robusta Colombian coffee.
The level of caffeine will be affected by the roast type. This is only where the coffee used is still Arabica coffee. Robusta coffee may have higher levels of caffeine, even if it is roasted in the same fashion.
Coffee lovers prefer whole bean coffee over ground options, and for that reason, our first two picks fall under this category. With the Don Pablo Colombian Supremo, you get to experience the cocoa toned flavor in all of its richness. Being GMO-free is a plus and means that you consume less chemicals as a whole.
The AmazonFresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee, on the other hand, is a whole bean option giving buyers quite a nice aroma. Quite a number of people also love the cocoa plus brown sugar flavors.
Those who use Keurig coffee makers also deserve the best coffee, which is where an option like the Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select comes in. The multiple flavors, including caramel, cocoa, plums, and apricots, make this coffee a joy to drink. Lastly, the convenience of using coffee pods is unmatched.
All the best as you select your Colombian coffee purchase from the list above.